Comments on: Jane Eyre (2006) Tenth anniversary Review – The Definitive Adaptation? https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review Romance That Entertains And Inspires Tue, 02 Apr 2024 22:37:40 +0000 hourly 1 By: Sharmon Heim https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-139686 Sat, 16 Mar 2024 21:10:26 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-139686 My thoughts exactly about the bedroom scene.

]]>
By: Amber Topping https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-135389 Fri, 02 Jun 2023 13:51:04 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-135389 In reply to Sara B..

Everyone has their favorite Jane Eyre adaptations, for sure. And not everyone will like this version. I disagree with your assessment but I always enjoy hearing other people’s interpretations! It’s interesting how people see and react in different ways based on experience. Thanks for sharing.

]]>
By: Sara B. https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-135286 Sat, 27 May 2023 20:11:34 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-135286 I think this is one of the weakest film adaptations of Jane Eyre. This version removes all the tension from Jane and Rochester‘s romance. In the book, we don’t know that Rochester has feelings for Jane until after Mason is bitten and packed off. In this version, it’s blatantly obvious that Rochester is in love with Jane before the house party even starts, thanks to the post-fire scene where you can cut the romantic and sexual tension with a knife (after two conversations? Really?) and the subsequent scene where Jane is practically sitting in Rochester‘s lap as he tells her about Celine Varens.
This plus the lack of chemistry between Blanche and Rochester mean that there’s never any question in the viewer’s mind about where Rochester’s heart lies. We know Blanche isn’t a rival and doesn’t present a threat to Jane’s happiness. Removing that element of potential conflict/obstacle makes the story significantly flatter and less interesting. It’s also too much work for the viewer to pretend that Toby Stephens and Ruth Wilson are physically unattractive.

]]>
By: Melanie https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-133900 Sat, 28 Jan 2023 23:51:26 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-133900 I just researched the mini series again (I own it but it’s been awhile since I’ve watched) and was reminded again how much I love it and how well it captures so much of the heart and depth of the novel. So many other adaptations miss the humor and wit within the characters in favor of too much solemnity. Jane’s sense of humor and personality is often cut or forgotten or downplayed. Rochester’s teasing wit is replaced with an overabundance of brooding. The 2006 version struck the impossible perfect balance of every emotion. I am always disappointed when I watch other versions. The only thing I disagree with is that I feel Stephens is every bit Rochester as Wilson is Jane. His expressions, the way he looks at her, the power and depth of emotion in his performace have yet to be matched by any other actor in the same role. The were perfectly paired and equally incredible. Other than the small discrepancies you mentioned in the script, everything about this adaptation is pure perfection.

]]>
By: Sheila https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-109459 Mon, 22 Mar 2021 05:22:20 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-109459 In reply to Janet Beal.

I heartily agree. I’ve watched most adaptations of Jane Eyre and I was captivated by the 2006 version. I’d never heard of Toby Stephens before this production and he will always be Rochester. I have watched hundreds of movies in my time but never have I watched anything that moved me so much as this story. Rochester goes through every scenario in the leaving scene he can think of searching for the one that will change her heart. Anyone who has had the person they love most walk away knows his agony.
When I think of couples in silhouette moments captured in film, one of the most famous was Scarlett and Rhett while Atlanta burned. Stephens and Wilson captured in silhouette and the passion on full display after the fire scene is mesmerizing. I was drawn in completely; I could feel myself standing in Jane’s place…breathtaking. And Toby Stephens’ profile is absolutely the most beautiful profile I’ve ever seen on a man…ever.
I read an article by a British columnist who groaned on about Toby Stephens being absolutely terrible casting choice. I don’t believe an actor ever made me swoon before.
Simply put, I love it.

]]>
By: Harriet https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-86848 Mon, 30 Nov 2020 03:13:47 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-86848 Ruth Wilson and Toby Stephens are the perfect Jane and Rochester. I can’t imagine Anyone else in the roles. I plan to watch the film for a third time and read the book again very soon.

]]>
By: mike B https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-23905 Tue, 21 Jan 2020 00:00:13 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-23905 I’m a little late commenting here but I just watched this Jane Eyre again and wanted to share my thoughts. My first exposure to Jane Eyre was this adaptation in 2008 and I knew nothing of the story; it was all new to me. I’m a sucker for English period pieces, but this was on a whole other level. Ms Wilson was simply amazing. All characters were very good, including Toby Stephens but the soul piercing performance of Ms Wilson is nothing short of miraculous. The proposal scene was a transfixing tour-de-force.

After this experience, I was eager to see other adaptations hoping for more magic. Unfortunately, they all fell short due to Ms Wilson’s unattainable performance. I can’t imagine anyone as Jane Eyre like I can’t imagine anyone other than Vivien Leigh as Scarlet O’hara.

]]>
By: janet Beal https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-5572 Wed, 29 Nov 2017 23:59:20 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-5572 Sorry, me again just to comment about whether the bedroom scene is true to Jane as a character, as you expressed.

I know that Jane rejects Rochester’s kisses and embraces after she discovers he’s married. Of course, this is because of her deep principles and self respect, but it’s also because she doesn’t trust herself. She wants him in the same way that all young people in love want each other. That’s why she has the most terrible internal struggle and has to flee real temptation. We know Jane is a passionate woman. She is exactly like Rochester in this regard – her soulmate , and we know how physical HE is. She rejects marriage to the cold fish St John, saying that she would be “forced to keep the fire of [her] nature continually low”. She has erotic dreams of Rochester, and describes her lost life with him in terms of “delirious with his love” and “fevered with …bliss”.

I think it’s important to convey to a modern audience this side of Jane’s character. To many, Jane is just a prim and proper Victorian governess in a rather chaste book, but that couldn’t be further from the truth. The novel is charged with sexuality. So I think viewers need to see the strong sexual bond that Jane has with Rochester, so that we can fully appreciate the enormous sacrifice she ultimately makes and the very great strength of character required to carry that through.

To that end, I think Sandy Welch’s treatment of the leaving scene is entirely justified. And fusing it with Jane’s sensual dreams makes it positively inspired!

]]>
By: Janet Beal https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-5568 Wed, 29 Nov 2017 16:26:32 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-5568 I love your review of my favourite adaptation of my favourite book! I particularly agree with the following: Ruth Wilson IS Jane, Toby’s effective portrayal of popularity, sarcasm and flirtatiousness, and Sandy Welch’s deep understanding of the novel.

I’d like to address your two complaints, if I may. Do you believe that the gypsy scene can be successfully screened? I doubt very much if it can. The few times I’ve seen it done I wasn’t convinced. It works on the page, but can’t be effectively transferred to the screen, in my opinion. I think Sandy Welch’s compromise of having a real gypsy act as the medium through which Rochester obtains information is so clever. We get to see just how desperate Rochester is for Jane to reveal herself, and just how ever-so-slightly bonkers he is! Lol. Yet Toby Stephens preserves his dignity intact!

Turning to the bedroom leaving scene, I used to be troubled by this. Then I reread chapter 32 of the book which describes Jane’s sensual dreams that she has about Rochester while she is in her cottage at Morton. She relates how she would awake in an empty bed and convulse with despair. Then I watched the bedroom scene in Jane Eyre 2006. The same awaking and crying with despair on her empty bed. Such a clever combining of the two scenes made possible because we are seeing this not chronologically but as a flashback from inside Jane’s tortured head. So, yes, this isn’t exactly how the leaving scene was written, but I would argue it captures like no other the essence of what Bronte wrote – the sensuality, arousal and despair.

I’d love to hear your thoughts!

]]>
By: Amber Topping https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/jane-eyre-2006-tenth-anniversary-review/#comment-5077 Wed, 16 Aug 2017 11:23:00 +0000 https://www.silverpetticoatreview.com/?p=32897#comment-5077 In reply to NyssaTheHobbit.

I know! It’s ridiculous how many streaming services are popping up left and right. Unfortunately, that means more and more great content will be pulled from Netflix, Amazon, Hulu, etc. because each “company” will want their own copyrighted work for themselves. The problem is that people don’t want to or can’t afford all of these different streaming services. Still, I think it likely Jane Eyre won’t make it back to Netflix for quite some time. Shame really…

]]>